REVIEW: Sanshiro Sugata (1943)

sanshiro1_posterIn the mid-1950s, when Japanese cinema finally started to get international recognition, it was largely through the films of Akira Kurosawa. His films struck a chord with festival audiences, and he soon become the most famous Japanese director in the world – although, perhaps surprisingly, he was never quite as enthusiastically embraced within his own country.

Films like Seven Samurai, Yojimbo and Rashomon remain immensely popular to this day, however Kurosawa did direct another 27 films – many of which are completely unknown to mass audiences. A few years ago I started on a personal mission to see all of them for myself, but in a switch of one blog to another I only got as far as 1952’s Ikiru. Time to restart that process for 2022, I think, and in preparation for that I am going to be lightly re-editing and re-posting those original Kurosawa reviews at FictionMachine.

It begins with Kurosawa’s 1943 directorial debut Sanshiro Sugata. The film is an adaptation of a Tsuneo Tomita novel, in which a brash young man named Sanshiro travels to Tokyo in order to learn jujitsu – but winds up learning the new martial art of judo instead.

Prior to directing Sanshiro Sugata Kurosawa had been working for Toho Studios as an assistant director, apprenticing under older, more experienced directors. When the offer was made for him to graduate to directing in his own right, it was Kurosawa who personally selected Tomita’s novel and suggested Toho purchase the film rights. The novel appeared to contain the right elements to pass by Japan’s war-time censors: it was upbeat and positive, seemed reasonably patriotic, and lacked anything that would get the film banned or excessively edited. In the end Kurosawa may have been slightly off the mark: one year after its initial release Sanshiro Sugata was aggressively edited by the censors, with 17 minutes of footage removed. That footage has never been recovered: the only version available today is the 79-minute 1952 cut, which is prefaced by a statement noting the absence of some scenes.

It is a remarkably American film in style: it is cut at a brisk pace, unlike its contemporaries, and Kurosawa directs a surprisingly fluid and mobile camera. There’s a lot of movement here in both the shots and the characters, and this contrasts against the more meditative, still aesthetic favoured by, say, Ozu or Mizoguchi. I suspect it is this American style that made Kurosawa so popular overseas, yet also generated the somewhat ambivalent response he often received at home. He may be telling a Japanese story, but he is certainly not telling it in a Japanese style.

Susumu Fujita plays Sanshiro with a sort of wide-eyed naivety. He’s brash, headstrong and doesn’t seem to know his own strength. In one early judo match he throws an opponent – an unlikeable, aggressive character – so hard that the man dies. Sanshiro is an odd combination of brute force and a sort of gentleness. He agrees to fight a middle-aged jujitsu fighter (a very appealing Takashi Shimura), and then agonises over participating in the fight once he meets the man’s beautiul daughter.

Ryunosuke Tsukigata plays the villainous Gennosuke Higaki. He does not simply want the chance to fight against Sanshiro in the ring, he wants to fight him to the death. That fight does come in an exceptionally shot climax on a grassy hill. Fierce winds whip the grass into a frenzy, making the entire environment reflect the vicious nature of the fight. It’s the best scene of the film, and points to a tremendous director just beginning to exert his talent. Higaki notably wears western clothing – a suit and a top hat – to bluntly present him as a villain to the anti-American audience.

All things considered, Sanshiro Sugata is a simplistic and relatively ordinary film, albeit one with occasional flashes of inventiveness and verve. You can see the Kurosawa with whom mainstream audiences are familiar peeking through the cracks, learning his craft and developing the confidence that will make him one of the all-time greats.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.