First broadcast 25 February 1982.

As the Urbankan spaceship speeds towards Earth, the Doctor (Peter Davison) discovers the truth about the ship’s captive humans. Adric (Matthew Waterhouse) is seduced by Monarch (Stratford Johns). Tegan (Janet Fielding) tries to escape the situation. Nyssa (Sarah Sutton) is hypnotised.

The first big surprise of “Four to Doomsday” part 3 is the discovery that all of the humans on the ship are robot duplicates of the originals. The Urbankans too have abandoned biological existence for life as robots, and plan to use a fatal toxin on the Earth’s population upon their arrival. It is a twist that makes some form of sense, given the thousands of years it has taken for the ship to make its journey. Soon Nyssa has been hypnotised and taken away to be converted into a robot as well. It is arguable that Nyssa is underserved by Terence Dudley’s script: with four regular characters in the series, it is a struggle to give each of them worthwhile material. It is no surprise there were plans to write Nyssa out during this serial at one stage.

Tegan’s increasing distress is put to good use: trying to escape, she manages to rematerialise the TARDIS outside of the spaceship. It is an interesting and previously unused crisis for the Doctor to overcome. Certainly, thinking back to when I first watched this serial as a child, it was one of the more memorable elements.

Adric spends the episode oversharing to Monarch about the TARDIS and its abilities. Monarch, of course, now wants to get inside, and puts on a charm offensive to get Adric to help him do that. Stratford Johns plays the scenes well – asides from his somewhat unconvincing make-up he makes for a decent antagonist all round – while Matthew Waterhouse struggles a little. It is not his fault: there is a term in writing called the “idiot ball”, where a character is figuratively thrown a scene where for plot purposes they are required to behave foolishly or irrationally – often at odds with their usual portrayal. There is more than a little of the phenomenon here. Adric is the most experienced of the Doctor’s companions here. This is his seventh adventure in the TARDIS. Furthermore he is written as a child prodigy. It is a strain to make him appear this credulous, and Waterhouse simply fails to manage it.

This episode really marks the beginning of Doctor Who‘s failure in regards to Adric. When introduced back in “Full Circle”, he is well written and interesting, and as a clever teenage boy marks a significant shift from earlier companions in the series. In “The Keeper of Traken” he is an excellently written and likeable character, developing what is a master-and-apprentice relationship with Tom Baker’s Fourth Doctor that most closely resembles Oliver Twist‘s Artful Dodger and Fagin. By “Four to Doomsday” that relationship has been abandoned. Peter Davison’s incarnation of the Doctor seems more exasperated with Adric than anything else. Nyssa has supplanted Adric’s position as the “clever youth”. His character and Tegan’s really do not fit well together. There really is not anywhere for the character to go but out – which he will do after another 15 episodes.

In the episode’s final minutes there is another twist. Monarch’s goal is not to colonise Earth but strip-mine it for minerals, use them to improve his ship, and then fly it back in time to the Big Bang and meet himself there. He believes he is a God. I do not think anyone in the audience saw that one coming.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending