In 2010 I was lucky enough to see Disney producer Roy Conli interviewed at the Australian Centre for the Moving Image (ACMI) in Melbourne. He was out promoting his upcoming animated feature Tangled at the time. During an audience question and answer session, he was asked about the risk of Tangled failing: if the film lost money, would Disney ever let him produce an animated film again. His response? ‘I produced Treasure Planet.’

John Musker and Ron Clements’ Treasure Planet, a labour of love for the beloved directing duo, was released to middling reviews and catastrophic box office. It came in the middle of a fallow period for Disney animation, after the end of the so-called Disney Renaissance (which Musker and Clements partially inspired) but before the Tangled-driven revival of the 2010s.

My wife and I struck up a conversation with Conli after his interview, and assured him that we both really liked Treasure Planet. ‘I liked Treasure Planet!’ he replied. ‘I liked it, you liked it, and the French liked it. But that’s it.’

Treasure Planet has long origins, since it was essentially Musker and Clements’ dream project from at least as early as 1985. Despite constant pitching to Disney, the directors were basically forced to make The Little Mermaid (1989), Aladdin (1992), and Hercules (1997) before they were finally given the green light. Treasure Planet was ultimately released in 2002.

It is a distinctly different film to its predecessors, and part of broader shift in Walt Disney feature animation. The studio was experimenting with a shift away from the Broadway musical format pioneered in The Little Mermaid. Tarzan (1999) featured non-diegetic songs rather than traditional musical numbers, while Treasure Planet‘s immediate predecessor Atlantis: The Lost Empire (2001) did not feature songs at all. That was something of a gamble at the time: in 2001 the highest-grossing non-musical animated film was still Miyazaki Hayao’s 1997 anime Princess Mononoke. Titan AE, a 20th Century Fox animated film that bore more than a passing similarity to Treasure Planet, had cost about USD$80 million and grossed less than half of that in cinemas. In retrospect it is somewhat surprising that Disney proceeded with Treasure Planet at all. I am glad that they did, despite the financial losses: it is an innovative and distinctive work, beautifully composed and entertaining.

Narratively it is a quite faithful adaptation of Robert Louis Stevenson’s novel Treasure Island, shifting the action into a fantastical sort of space environment. It keeps the nautical aesthetic of a novel: spaceships look like 18th century sailing vessels, and the entire work reflects a well-developed sort of ‘sailpunk’ style that enables it to stand out among other animated films of the time.

The characters are well-crafted, and each is given their own SF-inspired wrinkle on their literary forebears. Protagonist Jim Hawkins is the most conventional of them, but elsewhere the pirate Long John Silver becomes a cyborg, Captain Smollett gets a change in sex and species, and castaway Ben Gunn is reimagined as a comedic and eccentric robot. The voice acting is performed by an all-star cast including Joseph Gordon Levitt, Emma Thompson, Martin Short, and David Hyde Pierce. It even features the final performance by English cult actor Patrick McGoohan (The Prisoner) as the ill-fated traitor Billy Bones.

Treasure Planet was released at a time when traditional drawn animation was falling out of favour, and computer-generated works were ascendant in Hollywood. The transition played no small part in the film’s commercial failure, which is a shame: it represents perhaps the most accomplished blend of the two techniques ever released. Long John Silver remains an artistic and technological marvel, in that his cybernetic components are rendered in CGI and his biological half is hand-drawn. The end result is vivid to look at and technically seamless.

It is a shame that Treasure Planet failed so terribly, as in the context of Walt Disney’s oeuvre at the time it is clearly one of the best animated films of its decade. It remains deeply underrated, and ripe for re-assessment.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Trending